I’m giving the new and improved American Idol an “A.” It grabbed me in the first five minutes with an exciting opening segment that reintroduced us to the brand new panel of judges: Jennifer Lopez, Steven Tyler, and Randy Jackson. Two of those judges are the biggest rock and pop stars on the planet. Way to come back in a big way for Season 10, Idol.
Mario Anzuoni/Reuters
I was surprised that Steven Tyler was so soft and lovable. Aside from a few really silly (and weird) comments about some of the girls’ outfits, his critique of the contestants was thoughtful, humorous and spot on. He was not mean (it looks like no one is filling those mean shoes this season). He was honest and legitimately seemed excited by some of the kids, often banging the table to help keep beat or singing and swaying along. I loved it.
J-Lo looked amazing and I can’t even imagine how some of these kids can stand and sing in front of her after watching her in movies and on MTV all these years. She is taking on the “sweet” role but, unlike Paula, she doesn’t have big syrupy statements. Rather she talks like a caring big sister and often looked completely uncomfortable saying “no” to anyone, even the, um, BAD ones. I thought it made her real and more “Jenny from the Block” again.
Randy helps keep the American Idol as we know it in place while bringing his own producer credibility back to the panel. The Dawg actually seems more comfortable and forthcoming with his comments now that the other British guy isn’t there anymore. (Did Randy lose more weight again? He looks great.)
I’m really excited. I’m predicting a successful season, especially after checking out some of these early gold ticket holders. And with the new panel of judges, it’s looking like American Idol is back and better than ever.
Simon WHO?
join the conversation